If Mélanie Of La Salette Fabricated The La Salette Message Published In 1879 Then Please Explain: Mother Hearing Voices Stabs To Death Husband And Four Children

Voices will be heard in the air. Men will beat their heads against walls, call for their death, and on another side death will be their torment. Blood will flow on all sides. Our Lady of La Salette 19 Sept. 1846 (Published by Mélanie 1879)  

God will allow the old serpent to cause divisions among those who reign in every society and in every family. Our Lady of La Salette 19 Sept. 1846 (Published by Mélanie 1879)  

The true faith to the Lord having been forgotten, each individual will want to be on his own and be superior to people of same identity, they will abolish civil rights as well as ecclesiastical, all order and all justice would be trampled underfoot and only homicides, hate, jealousy, lies and dissension would be seen without love for country or family. Our Lady of La Salette 19 Sept. 1846 (Published by Mélanie 1879)  

4 children, man dead in 'horrendous' stabbing; mom detained

GWINNETT COUNTY, Ga. - Gwinnett County police said a man and four children were found stabbed to death in a Loganville home Thursday morning. When officers arrived at the home on Emory Lane, they found the victims dead. A fifth child was taken to the hospital with serious injuries. The mother of the children has been detained, according to police. Police said "specifics on the ages of the children or a motive for this horrendous crime is still unknown." The woman is being questioned at the Gwinnett County Police Department. Neighbors told Channel 2's Liz Artz that the victims are toddlers at the youngest, and the oldest is around 7 years old. She was told they moved here about a month ago from Illinois. Police spokesperson Michele Pihera said they believe they have everyone involved in this crime. "I don't want anybody in this community to think that we've got a mad person running around trying to stab somebody," Pihera said. Neighbors told Artz that the woman was depressed about her father dying. Source

Gee...please read the words from Our Lady at La Salette and then read the story and then tell me that Melanie fabricated the message that she published in 1879.

Because some envious souls claim that Melanie fabricated the whole thing!

Steve Skojec

Melanie fabricated this last message........as a cry for attention ~ Steve Skojec

The fact is, I'm in the attention business ~ Steve Skojec

Melanie's later secret has been held suspect for a long time as her own invention, largely because it took place so long after the original apparitions. In fact it is quite likely that Rome will become a seat of the Antichrist, as Cardinal Newman's own treatises (IIRC) on the Antichrist explain. But nonetheless, her statement on that comes from questionable material. ~ Steve Skojec

My understanding is that there have always been concerns that Melanie fabricated this last message later on, whether as a cry for attention (she was living a cloistered life, and perhaps missed the buzz of being a seer) or for some other reason. The earlier visions of La Salette are not in dispute. And of course, it's possible that this message is real. But without being able to verify its authenticity, it strikes me as a tenuous data point in arguing a case for moral certitude on an issue of this importance. I myself have cited this same message in the past, though with the caveat that we don't know if it is authentically from the Blessed Virgin. ~ Steve Skojec

No, not being warned to stay away from prophecy. Being warned that some prophecy is false, so stick to the good ones. All the approved apparitions of Our Lady seem to be applicable now, there are great riches to be found in Emmerich, properly understood, St. Hildegard von Bingen is apropos...there's a lot to choose from. Certain prophecies, however, give us cause for concern. And our eagerness to look for answers can offer a certain incentive to believe anything that sounds right. That is where the devil hooks us. ~ Steve Skojec

See more envious comments from Steve and his followers here

You can follow Steve Skojec at his blog One Peter Five here

Victim of Jesus nee MELANIE CALVAT, 
Shepherdess of La Salette

"I protest highly against a different text, which people may dare publish after my death. I protest once more against the very false statements of all those who dare say and write First that I embroidered the Secret; second, against those who state that the Queen Mother did not say to transmit the Secret to all her people." Melanie